Common myths about nuclear disasters
There are a lot of myths out there about what would happen if there were a nuclear explosion. There have been comments about who would survive, what conditions would be like and what areas have the most threat. We thought we’d address some of these issues.
A nuclear power plant could explode
While a nuclear water regulated reactor might have a meltdown, it’s impossible for a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) or Light Water Reactor (LWR) to explode like an atomic bomb.
This is because in order for an uncontrolled chain reaction to occur that is similar to an atom bomb, the uranium fuel must be extremely enriched, much more than the 4% 235U that is present in regular, commercial nuclear reactor fuel.
So, if it can’t explode, what does happen in a nuclear reactor? The answer is what is called a meltdown. When a meltdown occurs in a reactor, the reactor “melts”. That is, the temperature rises in the core so much that the fuel rods actually turn to liquid, like ice turns into water when heated. If the core continued to heat, the reactor would get so hot that the steel walls of the core would also melt. In a complete reactor meltdown, the extremely hot (about 2700 Celsius) molten uranium fuel rods would melt through the bottom of the reactor and actually sink about 50 feet into the earth beneath the power plant. The molten uranium would react with groundwater, producing large explosions of radioactive steam and debris that would affect nearby towns and population centers. (Read the Think Quest article.)
[polldaddy poll=6039519]
Cockroaches would survive a nuclear explosion
This actually depends on what level of radiation the cockroaches are exposed to. Cockroaches exposed to 1,000 to 10,000 rads lived for a month. However roaches exposed to 100,000 rads didn’t survive. This is still pretty impressive though, considering that humans wouldn’t survive a 1,000 rads within 10 minutes.
Food in an explosion would become radioactive and non-edible
There are three types of radiation during a fallout – alpha particles, beta particles and gamma rays. The first two are particles that can’t be seen by the naked eye. However, they can be simply washed off of many types of food.
In any case, these particles may be simply washed off many types of foods that have a natural covering, such as eggs, bananas, potatoes, oranges, etc., or off well sealed foods such as those in vacuum packed cans. Foods such as grains (rice, dry cereals, etc.) that are in partially used packages that have been opened should be viewed with suspicion. Fallout dust may have crept in.
The food in its unopened container or natural covering should be rinsed under flowing water and then placed on a surface that has been similarly cleansed, before opening. Make sure that the hands (and under the nails) have been thoroughly cleansed before handling the food. There is little danger in handling such articles. The radiation given off by these particles is so weak that it will often not even penetrate something as thin as the cellophane wrapper on a package of cigarettes. (Read Bruce Beach’s article.)
Radiation would be inescapable
This is not totally true. While everything at the base of the explosion would be pulverised, many of the effects of a nuclear bomb are due to the fallout – or the particles that fall from the plume.

If there is not a lot of wind, the fallout particles could be distributed within an hour of the explosion. And, the longer these particles are airborne, the less radiation they contain. (From the book, “Nuclear War Survival Skills.”)


Ready
Main Entrees
Mountain House on Sale!
So, if it can’t explode, what does happen in a nuclear reactor? The answer is what is called a meltdown. When a meltdown occurs in a reactor, the reactor “melts”. That is, the temperature rises in the core so much that the fuel rods actually turn to liquid, like ice turns into water when heated. If the core continued to heat, the reactor would get so hot that the steel walls of the core would also melt. In a complete reactor meltdown, the extremely hot (about 2700 Celsius) molten uranium fuel rods would melt through the bottom of the reactor and actually sink about 50 feet into the earth beneath the power plant. The molten uranium would react with groundwater, producing large explosions of radioactive steam and debris that would affect nearby towns and population centers. (



Thank you for the clear definitions. However, you failed to mention the affects of Gamma radiation and that new nuclear weapons have greater Gamma and less Alpha and Beta levels. Gamma penetrates up to six feet of reinforced concrete and will directly pass through most homes and shelters, thus killing everything inside.
Beta radiation will pass through normal walls and through clothes, although most can be washed off. You are correct about Alpha, but few realize that most nuclear devices put out small amounts of Alpha, unlike 40 years ago when your book was written, things have changed greatly in the nuclear weapons department.
March 15th, 2012 at 10:22 amJohn M is correct. Modern nuclear weapons and reactors would produce almost 90% of gamma radiation with the remainder in Alpha and Beta particles. Alpha particles most folks have to consume (through contaminated food and water) to be affected. Beta particles usually are inhaled which causes contamination. If you managed to consume or inhale Alpha and Beta particles, these particles basically play a microscopic game of “Pong” in your body which is what leads to illness and cancer, then death if not treated. But Gamma particles travel just like X-rays, only they aren’t stopped by bones and dense material. You have to have lead to stop Gamma particles. That is why gamma radiation is so dangerous. It can travel around the world on the jet stream, contaminating everything. It does not matter how long the particles are airborne, they are still radioactive and pose a danger to all life.
March 15th, 2012 at 11:26 amGamma radiation is responsible for most of the direct kill of a nuclear plant problem. Gamma has great penetration but is also not going to persist in the environment. In food irradiation plants the prevention of gamma spread is done through wave traps. Since gamma travels in a straight line you can objectively state that as long as there isn’t a gamma source you should be safe from gamma rays.
March 15th, 2012 at 12:32 pmThanks John! I really appreciate the comment. Ya, you’re right. The book was written in the 1980s.
March 15th, 2012 at 1:56 pmThis article is not only out of date it is virtually worthless. All you have to do is look at the epic Fukushima disaster.
What happens when a plant releases 400 to 700 pounds of plutonium and 20-100 TONS of uranium dust into a high altitude plume?
What happens when globally, as billions breathe in ‘hot’ particles on a daily basis, for years or generations, just from this plant?
We can only guess at the answers but research shows that we can count on some increased amount of birth defects, still births, weakened immune systems, increased cancers, and mutated viruses and bacteria.
There is virtually no way to avoid exposure but you can try to leach it out of your body by making a daily drink of either bentonite clay or zeolate (1 Tbls per cup) as both of these bind to toxins and heavy metals. The longer the radiation circles the globe the longer the internal exposure and even at small amounts it accumulates over time.
March 16th, 2012 at 2:53 am